新到中北帆的文章很好，看来是在生命科学领域中外都有过丰富经历的人士。何士刚充其量是位在国外科研做得不错，大概也获得过一个faculty职位，有可能申请过经费，见到过评审的意见，但置疑他被邀请评审过同行的申请。回国成了专家，有了无数的头衔，俺对此到是理解，谁让俺的大中国“院士也就相当于人家美国一位副教授”呢？有了头衔就干点实事吧，把您知道的、认为于中国科研有益的国外规范等在力所能及的范围内灌输到实际的工作中去，象北帆那样先从写评审项目的description开始。以士刚您的“傲气”，俺恶意地揣测您在评审项目时肯定把自己放在了权利至高的法官位置，生杀予夺您说了算。在您眼里，自己的永远是最好的，其他人的项目大都耽误。

北帆，向你致意，就因为您一句话【回国几年来我只见到我自己评审别人的项目时写的评语有对申请书内容的简述】。

士刚同学，您在评审项目时这样做了吗？要是不知道应该这么做，把问题贴到这儿来，能指教您的XYS坛子里也不少。

以下是俺最近评审的一个基金项目对评审内容的要求。士刚同学，不要说俺只知道指责您而没有建设性意见啊。

Pre-Meeting Critique
Criteria    Score    Status    Action
Description    N/A     Complete    View/Edit

Scientific Merit        Complete    View/Edit

Clinical Impact        Complete    View/Edit

Innovation        Complete    View/Edit

Feasibility        Complete    View/Edit

Expertise        Complete    View/Edit

Budget    N/A     Complete    View/Edit

Description
Provide a brief (four to six sentence) overall description of the proposed research. This paragraph should present an objective synopsis of the application, free of evaluative or critical comments.
Scientific Merit
Does the proposed research address the study hypothesis? Does the research use valid research and statistical methods and anticipate and remedy potential experimental problems to ensure effective resolution of the study hypothesis? How likely is it that the proposed research project and training program can be completed within the timeframe of the award?
Clinical Impact
Will the proposed research lead to substantial advances and/or contribute to large leaps of understanding or knowledge that will significantly hasten progress in finding and applying cures? Will the proposed research contribute substantially to reducing breast cancer incidence and/or mortality within the next decade?
Innovation
To what extent does the proposed research introduce ideas, methods, or devices that are substantially different from existing approaches or use existing approaches or devices/technologies in novel ways? To what extent does the proposed research challenge existing paradigms, research methods, and/or clinical practice?
Feasibility
How likely is it that the proposed research goals and milestones will be achieved within the scope of the funded project?
Expertise
To what extent do the PI/Co-PI and his/her research team have the expertise to effectively implement all aspects of the proposed research?
Budget
Is the budget appropriate for the proposed research?